Why Failing Forward is the Secret to Exceptional Leadership
Leadership isn’t about perfection, it’s about progress. The most transformative leaders don’t avoid mistakes; they leverage them to drive growth, innovation, and resilience. Yet, too many leaders fear failure, seeing it as a weakness rather than a catalyst for mastery.
Here’s the truth: The biggest leadership failure isn’t making mistakes, it’s refusing to learn from them.
In this blog, we’ll explore:
✔ Why failure is your greatest teacher (and how elite leaders reframe setbacks)
✔ The costly consequences of repeating the same mistakes
✔ Real-world examples of leaders who crashed, and those who thrived
✔ Actionable strategies to build an unshakable growth mindset
Whether you’re a CEO, manager, or rising leader, this guide will help you turn stumbling blocks into stepping stones.
Why Failure is Non-Negotiable in Leadership
Research from Harvard Business Review reveals that organisations with psychologically safe cultures (where failure is a learning tool) outperform peers by 21%. Why? Because innovation requires risk, and risk inevitably brings setbacks.
Yet, many leaders still operate from a fear-based mindset, avoiding bold decisions to dodge potential failure. This creates stagnation, the true enemy of success.
The Three Leadership Traps
The Perfectionist Trap – Obsessing over flawless execution kills agility.
The Blame Game – Pointing fingers stifles accountability and trust.
The Short-Term Fix – Prioritising quick wins over long-term growth.
Leaders who fall into these traps miss the hidden lessons in every setback.
The Real Cost of Not Learning from Failure
Case Study 1: Blockbuster’s Billion-Dollar Blind Spot
In the early 2000s, Blockbuster dominated video rentals—until Netflix emerged. CEO John Antioco dismissed streaming as a niche trend, refusing to pivot. The result? Bankruptcy by 2010.
Lesson: Complacency is failure in slow motion.
Case Study 2: Kodak’s Innovation Paradox
Kodak invented the digital camera in 1975, but buried the tech to protect film sales. By the time they adapted, competitors like Canon had seized the market.
Lesson: Fear of cannibalising success leads to irrelevance.
The Contrast: Leaders Who Leaned Into Failure
Steve Jobs – Fired from Apple in 1985, he returned with breakthrough innovations like the iPhone.
Sara Blakely (Spanx) – Rejected by manufacturers 20+ times before building a billion-dollar brand.
Key Insight: Failure only becomes fatal when you stop iterating.
How to Build a Failure-Proof Leadership Mindset
1. Reframe Setbacks as Data Points
Instead of asking, “Why did this go wrong?” ask:
“What is this teaching me?”
“How can I apply this lesson moving forward?”
Example: Amazon’s Fire Phone flopped, but its tech later powered Alexa and AWS.
2. Foster Psychological Safety
Teams that fear blame hide mistakes. Encourage transparency by:
✔ Publicly sharing your own failures (modelling vulnerability)
✔ Rewarding smart risks (even if outcomes fall short)
✔ Running “post-mortems” without punishment
Google’s Project Aristotle found this is the #1 trait of high-performing teams.
3. Adopt the 70% Rule
Waiting for perfect conditions? You’ll miss your window. Elite leaders act when they have 70% certainty, then adjust mid-course.
4. Build Resilience with Micro-Failures
Start small:
Test new ideas in low-stakes scenarios.
Debrief openly on what worked (and what didn’t).
Normalise “failing fast” to accelerate learning.
Your Turn: Turning Failure into Fuel
Great leaders aren’t defined by their stumbles—but by their ability to rise stronger.
Action Steps This Week:
Journal one recent “failure” – What did it reveal?
Share a lesson with your team – Normalise the conversation.
Pilot one experimental idea – Embrace the 70% rule.
Remember: The only true failure is the lesson you refuse to learn.
Want to Cultivate Fearless Leadership in Your Organisation?
At Verde Vitae, we help leaders and teams thrive through resilience training, mindset coaching, and high-performance strategies.to build a culture where failure fuels growth.
Learn more about EQ workshops, coaching, and tailored leadership programmes with Verde Vitae.
If you liked this quick notes article you might like this one too:
Top 5 Corporate Wellness Trends in the UK for 2025
Authentic Leadership: How to Lead with Confidence and Stay True to Yourself
